Matt Gutman Apologizes After Calling Alleged Charlie Kirk Shooter’s Messages “Very Touching”

ABC’s Matt Gutman is under fire for describing text messages from Tyler Robinson to his transgender partner as “very touching.” Here’s what happened, why it sparked backlash, and what we now know about Tyler Robinson, Lance Twiggs, and the investigation.

Matt Gutman Faces Backlash Over ‘Touching’ Comments About Killer’s Messages

ABC News correspondent Matt Gutman recently came under intense criticism for calling text messages between alleged Charlie Kirk assassin Tyler Robinson and his romantic roommate “very touching.” The messages, revealed during a press conference, showed Robinson addressing his partner—Lance Twiggs, who is transgender—with affectionate language. Gutman later apologized, saying he regretted how his remarks were perceived.

The Texts That Sparked Controversy

During an official presentation, prosecutors disclosed messages allegedly sent by Tyler Robinson to Lance Twiggs. These texts reportedly included phrases like “my love” and expressed concern for Twiggs’s well-being. Robinson allegedly asked Lance to destroy or conceal evidence tied to the crime and encouraged him to avoid law enforcement contact. The juxtaposition of warm, intimate language with the violent act Robinson is accused of shocked many observers.

Public & Media Reaction

When Gutman described the messages as “touching,” many viewers reacted unfavorably. Critics argued that it humanizes someone accused of a violent crime, potentially glossing over the severity of the event. Others felt the commentary veered into sensationalism or sympathy toward the accused rather than focusing on accountability. The critique spread across social media platforms, with calls for clearer boundaries in how media handles emotional content in criminal cases.

Matt Gutman’s Apology

In response to the backlash, Gutman made a public apology, acknowledging that his choice of words undermined the gravity of Charlie Kirk’s killing. He clarified that he meant to highlight the tragic contrast between the brutal act and the personal multimedia evidence. Gutman stated that he fully condemns the murder, emphasizing sorrow for Kirk’s family and the wider impact of the crime.

Who Are Tyler Robinson & Lance Twiggs?

Tyler Robinson, 22, was arrested for the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk during a speaking event at Utah Valley University. Robinson lives in Utah and has been charged with multiple crimes, including aggravated murder. His romantic partner and roommate, Lance Twiggs, is reportedly transgender and resides with Robinson in St. George, Utah.

Authorities say Lance Twiggs has cooperated with the investigation, sharing text messages and communications with Robinson that were discovered after the event. Although deeply involved in the personal side of the unfolding story, there is no indication that Twiggs is accused of participating in the crime itself.

Investigation Details & Motives

Prosecutors allege Robinson used a rifle gifted by a family member in the shooting. Evidence collected includes surveillance footage, text exchanges, and witness testimony. The crime took place from a rooftop roughly 200 yards away, with Robinson allegedly firing while Kirk addressed a crowd. The motive isn’t fully confirmed but appears to involve political, ideological, and online radicalization elements.

Why This Case Stirs Strong Reactions

This case combines multiple flashpoints: it involves a high-profile shooting of a well-known conservative figure, political polarization, issues of gender identity, the use of intimate text messages in legal proceedings, and media ethics. All these layers amplify public scrutiny. Media professionals, commentators, and viewers are debating how much humanity one should ascribe to an accused killer, and whether expressions of affection should be reported on with care, especially alongside the severity of such an alleged crime.

Matt Gutman’s Role & Reputation

Matt Gutman is a senior national correspondent for ABC News, often covering crime, culture, and large-scale events. He has a longstanding reputation for presenting stories visually and emotionally powerful, though this incident has put him in the crosshairs of critics who demand more cautious commentary in cases involving loss of life and public trauma. His apology indicates acknowledgment that his role as a media presenter includes managing not only what is reported, but how it’s reported.

Legal Proceedings & What’s Next

Robinson faces multiple serious charges, and prosecutors plan to seek the death penalty. The investigation continues, with authorities examining digital evidence, messages, and possible ideological motivations. Lance Twiggs’s cooperation means some pieces of Robinson’s online activity and personal communications may be central to both prosecution and defense narratives. The case is likely to unfold with more disclosures over time.

Media Ethics & Responsibility

This situation also raises questions about media responsibility. How should journalists cover moments of shared human vulnerability without overshadowing the crime itself? Is it ethical to describe someone accused of murder as showing love? How do we balance emotional context with accountability? The debate suggests that future coverage may lean more cautious, with media outlets rethinking their framing when victims, accused, and personal relationships are involved in criminal proceedings.

Conclusion

The story of Matt Gutman, Tyler Robinson, and Lance Twiggs is unfolding rapidly. On one hand, it’s a legal case involving the assassination of a public figure. On the other, it’s a human story with elements of intimacy, conflict, identity, and ideology. Gutman’s remarks and apology show how sensitive the intersection of crime, media, and personal relationships can be. As the legal case progresses, so will public debates about how stories like this are told, who is humanized, and how words matter when tragedies occur.

#MattGutman #TylerRobinson #LanceTwiggs #CharlieKirk #MediaEthics #CrimeNews #Utah